City Methodist Church

The ruined main hall of the abandoned City Methodist Church in Gary, Indiana: tall stone columns, a large Gothic window and fallen boards and debris across the floor
Artwork FileGary · Indiana

City Methodist Church

StandingNov 2026

Gothic Revival church, first service 1926, closed 1975 · Washington Street, Gary

Photo: Peter Fitzgerald / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0), taken 31 July 2009. Full photograph shown.

  • #CityMethodistChurch
  • #Gary
  • #Indiana
  • #GothicRevival
  • #Demolition
  • #AbandonedChurch

City Methodist Church in downtown Gary was built with help from U.S. Steel and was once called the largest Methodist church in the Midwest. It closed in 1975 and was damaged by fire in 1997. In September 2026 a demolition contract was awarded, and the city expects it to be gone by August 2027. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · City of Gary · Indiana Historic Preservation Review Board Checked

As of the newest dated report found (Chicago Sun-Times, 2 November 2026), the church was still standing; the city said site staging and abatement would begin the week of 12 October 2026. No report that the building itself has started coming down was found on 16 November 2026. Chicago Sun-Times, 2 Nov 2026 · City of Gary Checked

More photos

The Gothic stone front and tower of the abandoned City Methodist Church on Washington Street in Gary, with a burned-out wing and a tall brick tower block behind
2019 The street front and towerPhoto: Paul Sableman / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

4 things to know

  1. Built with steel moneyAccording to the Chicago Sun-Times, U.S. Steel gave $350,000 toward the church, which held its first service in October 1926. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Reported
  2. More than a sanctuaryAccording to Wikipedia, the church also had a gym, a theater, a cafeteria and commercial space. Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Reported
  3. Closed, then burnedThe church closed in 1975, and a fire in 1997 damaged the empty building. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · Indiana Historic Preservation Review Board Checked
  4. Coming down by 2027Homrich Wrecking holds the demolition contract. The city expects the work to be finished by 24 August 2027. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · City of Gary Checked

Where it is

📍
Corner of Sixth Avenue and Washington Street, downtown Gary, Indiana. The City of Gary and the state review board give 549 Washington Street; the Chicago Sun-Times gives 577 Washington Street. The map point is the coordinate used by Wikipedia. City of Gary · Indiana Historic Preservation Review Board · Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Conflicting
🧭
The button opens a map search at the church; no Street View image is used as evidence.

Sightings

  1. 19263 Oct

    First service in the new church

  2. 1975

    Church closes

  3. 1997

    Fire damages the empty building

  4. 200931 Jul

    Ruined main hall photographed

  5. 20195 Jan

    Front and tower still standing

  6. 202516 Apr

    State board approves demolition

  7. 2026Sep

    Demolition contract awarded

  8. 202612 Oct

    Staging and abatement set to begin

Every stamp links to its source. Amber stamps are dates from records and reports; green stamps are dated photographs.

On the record

Chicago Sun-Times5 September 2026

Once the largest Methodist church in the Midwest is slated for demolition

“The long-vacant and decaying City Methodist Church — at one time the largest Methodist church in the Midwest — is slated for demolition, more than 50 years after it closed.”

Read the source

FOX 32 Chicago21 September 2026

Century-old City Methodist Church in Gary slated for demolition

“A century-old church in Gary is slated for demolition despite years of work trying to save the structure.”

Read the source

The facts

First service
3 October 1926, according to Wikipedia. Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Reported
Architects
Lowe & Bollenbacher of Chicago, according to Wikipedia. Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Reported
Funding
U.S. Steel gave $350,000 toward construction, according to the Chicago Sun-Times; Wikipedia says the company paid almost half of the cost. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · Wikipedia, City Methodist Church Reported
Listed
Contributing building in the Gary City Center Historic District, National Register of Historic Places, 1994. Indiana Historic Preservation Review Board Reported
Demolition
Contract to Homrich Wrecking, about $5.3 million, awarded in September 2026; completion expected by 24 August 2027. Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Sep 2026 · City of Gary Checked
Our photo
Peter Fitzgerald, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0, 31 July 2009.

Related

All sources (8)

Artwork File · Last checked 16 November 2026 · Certainty labels follow How We Verify Art · All Artwork Files

Our sister site

More on World Art Utopia